• Home
  • About
  • Current Listings
  • Our Townhouse
  • City Favorites

Yours Most Sincerely

Love Letters from the Good Life

Real Estate / March 26, 2021

538 Garden Drive, Cherokee Gardens

For the discriminating Buyer, one of Louisville’s historic and most desirable neighborhoods presents an available beauty.  Stately three-story, center-hall Colonial in Cherokee Gardens offers a perfect combination of century-old character and modern amenities.  Sloping front yard welcomes visitors to a home overlooking Cherokee Gardens common space.   

Just inside the original front door, a wide foyer lends a welcoming touch.  To the left, a formal living room offers plenty of space for seating areas and large furniture and is centered around a lovely ventless gas fireplace with original mantle and surround.  The light here from East and Northeast facing windows is a soft and romantic contrast to the adjoining sunroom.  Here, French doors open to the drive, allowing for easy entry, while full windows on two walls suggests an outdoor feeling while relaxing inside.  Original brick wall and tile flooring make this room the perfect informal gathering space.  Spacious formal dining room at the front of the house is open to the foyer, and boasts Scalamandre wallpaper as well as two custom hand painted light fixtures.  There is ease of access here to the kitchen area, which comprises almost a third of the first floor square footage.  Informal eating area, butler’s pantry and the kitchen are centered around an incredible feature; the original brick incinerator chute!  While the current owners considered opening this entire space to renovate into a dreamy chef’s kitchen, they fell for the mosaic backsplash and simple cabinetry, adding Danby marble counters and backsplash, and updating appliances.  The butler’s pantry provides storage not often found in homes of this age, as well as a tucked away prep or bar space, and a beverage fridge.  Eating area opens to the rear yard via a wall of glass doors.  The first floor powder room is a surprise of a jewel box, with stunning Thibaut wallpaper and custom vanity.   

The gracious staircase boasts a bold animal print runner.  At the front of the second floor, the owners have reimagined a once small and cramped bathroom and two bedrooms into an amazingly large primary suite.  Bedroom boasts a fireplace of it’s own, with 4 windows, yet plenty of privacy.  The original closet here remains.  Primary bath is a vision in white; counter-height vanity stretches the width of the room and offers an incredible amount of storage.  The walk-in shower here has built-in storage nook.  Without wanting to remove or alter the over-sink windows here, an ingenious solution to vanity mirrors was sourced: these bend out to provide the necessary reflection for daily routines, and fold flat against side walls when not in use.  Bathroom opens to a Pinterest-worthy walk-in closet.  Here, built-in storage on all walls and hand-painted wallpaper combine to provide a wealth of storage and style.  At the rear of the second floor, two more bedrooms (one with double closets and a door to a Juliet balcony) and a sunny corner office share an all-marble hall bath with walk-in shower and soaking tub.  An original Murphy ironing board and bright and functional laundry room sit side-by-side in the hall.   

The third floor houses two more bedrooms, each with closet and storage space as well as dormer windows overlooking the fantastic treetops of the Cherokee Gardens neighborhood, and share another full bath.  

Rear yard is lushly landscaped and private.  Owners love the size here, and have used the added covered rear porch as well as the secured parking pad and the yard as one large entertaining area.  Two-car garage had center beam removed and happily houses two large SUVs.  Don’t be fooled by the appearance, here.  A custom door has the look of period-appropriate separate bays, but is a single door opening to one large space.   

Owners were meticulous in preserving all that they could; This beauty still has many of the original and unique period features like basement wine cellar and old incinerator hood, glass doorknobs and original hardwood floors and linen storage.  With custom window treatments, plantation shutters, sprinkler system, exterior lighting, alarm system, and updated light fixtures, however, a masterpiece has blossomed.   

Easy accessibility to the Ursuline Campus, Interstate 64, St. Matthews and Crescent Hill.  Seneca Park and the Scenic Loop to Cherokee Park are within walking distance.  Situated close to some of Louisville’s most awe-inspiring original architecture as well as all of the local eateries along Frankfort Avenue and shopping on Shelbyville Road, one cannot beat the location of such a distinctive property, and with such care in preserving the integrity of this beauty over the years, one will not find a more incredible place to call home.

Professionally marketed by Joyce Duncan Mills, Semonin REALTORS.

For more information, click here.

** photos by Don Lehman **


Share This Post

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Maybe it’s due to an overactive mind, a desire to feel like I’m influencing someone, or perhaps, it’s simply that I need to talk.

READ MORE

Subscribe via Email

Receive our posts via email

keep in touch

Sponsors

Looking for Something?

A friend of mine asked me recently if we’d final A friend of mine asked me recently if we’d finally built our dream kitchen. It’s close. It’s pretty darn close. Carrara marble everywhere, beveled subway tile backsplash, black Bertazzoni range... it’s pretty close 💕
Kentucky’s tulip trees will forever have my hear Kentucky’s tulip trees will forever have my heart.
Our new powder room may or may not be going a litt Our new powder room may or may not be going a little overboard with Fornasetti everything. Here, their Nuvolette wallpaper in the dark blue colorway and one of 2 or 3 wall plates that’ll top the walls.
Wrapped up the first week of the new year by worki Wrapped up the first week of the new year by working from home, setting intention for 2021, and planning client parties, holiday gatherings. Hoping your new year is off to the best start. Cheers, y’all.
Wishing you the most beautiful Christmas. This yea Wishing you the most beautiful Christmas. This year hasn’t been the easiest on anyone, and the holidays may be difficult. I hope you find the light this season, and that even if Christmas Day is spent alone, I hope that the quiet and the snow, the light of the tree and the music on the radio provide a heart full of love.
While the man and I aren’t really doing a beauti While the man and I aren’t really doing a beautiful table setting this year (we have paper plates and a folding table), or roasting a huge bird and hosting 20 people for board games and bourbon (it’ll be turkey meatballs for two, because... Covid), I still wanted to throw some inspiration out there. This is my favorite Thanksgiving tablescape from 2017. This table is on the blog now! Cheers, y’all.
Coming soon: a century-old beauty that you just ha Coming soon: a century-old beauty that you just have to see. Keep your eyes peeled, y’all, for an Old Louisville mansion hitting the market next week.
So hard to believe our gorgeous home is on the mar So hard to believe our gorgeous home is on the market... so many years here, and so many changes in our lives. This house has seen the loss of both our dogs, both my parents. We celebrated our engagement here, came home happy and silly after a Christmas elopement. Thanksgiving here has been full of Bourbon and friends and Trivial Pursuit.  This has been my happy place for the better part of a decade. 

Going to sleep tonight in hopes of the right buyer who will love these walls as much as we have 💕
© 2021 Yours Most Sincerely / Designed + Created by Jelly Design Studio / Disclosure